• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
The Fund For Modern Courts

The Fund For Modern Courts

Improving the administration of justice in New York State

  • Letter from our Chair
  • Our Board
  • Donate
  • Login
  • Home
  • Initiatives
    • Family Court Reform
    • Civil Legal Services
    • Town and Village Courts
    • The Judiciary Article of the NYS Constitution
    • Court Simplification
    • Judicial Selection
    • Judicial Diversity
    • Immigrants & State Courts
    • Amicus Project
    • Citizen Court Monitoring
    • Education and Outreach
    • Finding Legal Resources for the Public
  • About Us
    • Officers & Board
    • FMC Staff
    • The Committee For Modern Courts
  • Awards & Events
    • Annual Fall Award Honorees
    • Robert M. Kaufman Award
    • Fern Schair Public Service Award
    • Cyrus R. Vance Tribute - History
    • Hugh R. Jones Memorial Lecture
    • Samuel J. Duboff Memorial Award
  • Publications
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Letter from our Chair
  • Our Board
  • Member Login

Front CTA

This page explains each judicial selection method, how each has been adapted in New York, and why Modern Courts endorses merit selection. It also outlines Modern Courts’ recent policy statements.

Selection of Judges

Methods of Judicial Selection

There are two primary methods of judicial selection: election and appointment. Most states, including New York, opt for a hybrid of elective and appointive positions.
Read More

Historical Background of Merit Selection

In early statehood, selection of judges conformed to the English tradition of appointment. In 1846, the process moved entirely to an elected judiciary. Today there is a hybrid of elected and appointed judges in the state.
Read More

Judicial Selection in the Courts of New York

This article explains how judges are selected for each court in the New York State court system.
Read More

Why We Support an Appointed System

Merit selection eliminates the role of money and significantly reduces the role of politics in judicial selection while providing for selection of highly-qualified judges by representatives of diverse groups of people.
Read More

We seek to make the the NYS Court system accessible and fair to all New Yorkers.

Initiatives

  • Town & Village Justice Courts
  • Fines & Fees
  • Family Court Reform
  • Court Simplification
  • Immigrants & State Courts
  • Public Libraries & Legal Research
  • Citizen Court Monitoring
  • Eviction Proceedings
  • Advocacy Whitepapers
  • Amicus Briefs

Primary Sidebar

Related Pages

  • Do It Yourself (DIY) Forms & Document Assembly
  • Language Access
  • Civil Legal Service Providers in New York State
  • Access To Justice
  • Williams-Yulee v. Florida Bar
  • Caperton v. A. T. Massey Coal Company, Inc.
  • NYS Board of Elections v. Lopez Torres
  • Hurrell Harring v. State of New York
  • Board Members Portal
  • Cyrus R. Vance Tribute 2023 – Hon. Rolando T. Acosta
  • Jeffrey L. Kessler – 2023 McCloy Honoree
  • Barbara S. Jones – 2023 Fern Schair Public Service Award Honoree
  • 2023 McCloy Sponsors
  • 2023 Annual Fall Awards
  • Donate Test
  • Cyrus R. Vance Tribute 2024 – Hon. Rowan D. Wilson, Chief Judge, State of New York
  • Susan Kohlmann – 2024 Robert M. Kaufman Award Honoree
  • Janet Sabel – 2024 Fern Schair Public Service Award Honoree
  • Award Presentation Sponsors – 2024
  • 2024 Annual Fall Awards Event
  • Letitia James, Attorney General, State of New York
  • Cyrus R. Vance Tribute 2025 – Hon. Letitia James, Attorney General of New York State
  • Faith Gay – 2025 Robert M. Kaufman Award Honoree
  • Andrew Celli – 2025 Robert M. Kaufman Award Honoree
  • Matthew Diller – 2025 Fern Schair Public Service Award Honoree
  • Statement of the Fund for Modern Courts – The Appointment of a New Chief Judge
  • Statement of the Fund for Modern Courts – The Appointment of a New Chief Judge (excerpt)
  • Sheila S. Boston – 2022 McCloy Honoree
  • Hon. John Gleeson – 2022 Career Public Service Award Honoree
  • Letter from our Chair
  • Hon. Juanita Bing Newton – 2021 Career Public Service Award Honoree
  • Brad Karp, Esq. – 2021 McCloy Honoree
  • Foo Test
  • John McCloy Award – Tuesday October 12, 2021
  • foo
  • test-video
  • John McCloy Award Video 2020
  • Tribute (Ad) Specifications
  • Donate
  • Court Observation Projects Slides
  • counties-p3
  • counties-p2
  • NYCourts.gov – Court Help
  • Online Legal and Court Information
  • Public Access Law Libraries
  • Guide to the NY State Court System
  • State Court vs. Federal Court Issues
  • Legal Information vs. Legal Advice
  • Access to Justice – Entry Points
  • Librarians on the Front Line
  • The “Justice Gap”
  • Librarians and Legal Resources Slide Presentation
  • Finding Legal Resources for the Public
  • Other Matters
  • Resources: The Constitutional Limit on the Number of Justices in the Supreme Court
  • Public Policy Relating to Judicial Selection
  • Structure of the Courts
  • Amending the NYS Constitution
  • The Judiciary Article of the NYS Constitution
  • Harlan A. Levy – 2016 John McCloy Memorial Award
  • Amicus Project
  • Immigrants & State Courts
  • Vance Tribute 2013 – Hon. P. Gail Prudenti
  • 2013 Duboff Award Recipients
  • 2012 Hugh R. Jones Lecture
  • Vance Tribute 2011 – Hon. Eric Schneiderman
  • Duboff Award 2008 – LIFT
  • Duboff Award 2012 – LILAC
  • 2003 Cyrus R. Vance Tribute
  • 2004 Cyrus R. Vance Tribute
  • 2005 Cyrus R. Vance Tribute
  • 2006 Cyrus R. Vance Tribute
  • 2007 Cyrus R. Vance Tribute
  • 2008 Cyrus R. Vance Tribute
  • Cyrus R. Vance Tribute
  • Wesley Finds Trend in Modern Research on Court Is Flawed
  • 2002 Hugh R. Jones Memorial Lecture
  • Former Court of Appeals Judge Levine Defends Common Law Adjudication
  • 2003 Hugh R. Jones Memorial Lecture
  • Judge argues for ‘human dimension of the law’
  • Ex-Judge Hancock Makes a Case For the Human Dimension in Law
  • 2004 Hugh R. Jones Memorial Lecture
  • 2005 Hugh R. Jones Memorial Lecture
  • 2006 Hugh R. Jones Memorial Lecture
  • 2007 Hugh R. Jones Memorial Lecture
  • Hugh R. Jones Memorial Lecture
  • John McCloy Award Recipients
  • Annual Fall Award Honorees
  • Samuel J. Duboff Memorial Award Recipients
  • Samuel J. Duboff Memorial Award
  • Juvenile Justice System Faces Conflicts Over Primary Goals
  • Judges Applaud Domestic Violence Courts
  • Domestic Violence Project Falls Short of Integrated Courts
  • Judicial Oversight has its Limits
  • Public Offered Insight into Judicial Discipline
  • The Committee For Modern Courts
  • Juveniles and the Courts
  • Integrated Domestic Violence Courts
  • Commission on Judicial Conduct
  • New Initiatives in Adoption
  • Testimony of Daniel R. Murdock
  • Policy Statement on Judicial Salaries
  • Justice for All: Accessing Quality Justice in New York State
  • Focus on Mental Health Courts
  • Witness to Justice: Reopening New York State Courtrooms to Camera Coverage
  • Picking Judges: How To Do It and Why It Matters
  • Matrimony Matters: Improving the Process for Families in Transition
  • Perspectives on Criminal Jurisdiction in Town and Village Justice Courts: Is There Justice in Justice Courts?
  • Challenges to Justice in Domestic Violence Cases in New York State: Gaps, Successes and the Future
  • Legal Services in a Time of Crisis: Policy, Practice and Economics
  • Education and Outreach
  • Citizen Court Monitoring
  • Civil Legal Services
  • Family Court Reform
  • Town and Village Courts
  • Judicial Diversity
  • Court Simplification
  • FMC Staff
  • Officers
  • Why We Support an Appointed System
  • Judicial Selection in the Courts of New York
  • Historical Background of Merit Selection
  • Methods of Judicial Selection
  • Information and Perspective on How Judges are Chosen in New York State
  • Contact
  • Publications
  • News
  • The Fund For Modern Courts
  • Awards & Events
  • Initiatives

Copyright © 2025 · site by iKnow